For example, the darkening stands out more in normally pale sugar cookies than in a deep brown pumpkin spice loaf. A Web Experience brought to you by LEAFtv, Joy of Baking: Baking Ingredient Substitution Table, Better Homes and Gardens: How to Substitute Brown Sugar for White Sugar, Serious Eats: Cookie Science - The Real Differences Between Brown and White Sugars, 3 Easy Steps On How To Substitute Sparkling Water In Baking, How to Make Cookies Crack on Top When Baked, The Difference Between Strudel & Streusel. ), but more of a “yes, but”… In most baking recipes, you can substitute brown sugar for white sugar in a one-to-one ratio. Pamela Follett/Demand Media Determine whether raw sugar, white granulated sugar or unsulfured light molasses are in your pantry to use as the substitute ingredient for the brown sugar. You can easily swap erythritol with white sugar. There's one caveat here, though. Since brown sugar is regular sugar with molasses, you can also substitute the other way around, too. This means you may have to adjust some of the other proportions in the recipe if you sub in brown sugar for white, like slightly decreasing the wet ingredients or upping the dry ones. You may need to bake it a little longer, but not too much longer. Brown sugar will also add a hint of rich caramel flavor and affect the color. PieceOfLayerCake May 3, 2017. It's more or less noticeable depending on what you're making. Measure the same amount of turbinado sugar. In a pinch, white sugar in an equal amount will work fine as a brown sugar replacement. In baked goods, turbinado sugar can replace granulated white sugar using a 1:1 ratio. For example, if the recipe requires 1 cup of granulated white sugar, use 1 cup of turbinado sugar. Alas, it will still be a fruitcake. If you want something healthy make carrot cake; you can use your brown sugar there. Lv 4. Other sugars, such as honey, brown faster and make much darker cakes. In some cases, it enhances it, as with the warm, fall flavors of gingerbread, pumpkin, apple, chai, cinnamon, nutmeg and clove. Measure the same amount of turbinado sugar. Powered sugar by the way, is too light for cheesecake. Golden caster sugar: loosely packed and sandy in texture with a warm, golden colour, golden caster sugar is a fine sugar that is ideal for use in creamed sponge cakes. Brown sugarcontains molasses, which may change the texture and flavor your baked goods, but the sweetness level will be the same. If a recipe calls for light brown sugar and you’re out, mix 1 cup granulated sugar … So if your recipe calls for 1 cup white sugar, swap 1 cup brown sugar. Granulated white sugar is a dry, freely flowing grain that naturally f… Different types of sugar Brown sugars. This can impart a slightly acidic bite and a mildly bitter flavor, but it's typically not pronounced enough to detract from the quality of the food. In my chocolate and carrot cake recipes, I have switched completely to brown and will never go back. When you substitute brown sugar for white sugar, the most significant effects – and the hardest to predict – are usually related to certain characteristics. For just one more common example, if a recipe uses softened or melted butter, the two types of sugar have different effects on gluten development during baking. When measuring it, pack it down into the cup or spoon so it actually fills the entire space. Stir together and use according to your recipe. Using brown sugar instead of white sugar won't affect the sweetness of the finished product, but it does alter the taste a bit. Beat in the flour mixture alternately with the milk, mixing just until incorporated. For every cup of brown sugar called for in your recipe, substitute 1 cup (198g) white granulated sugar and 2 teaspoons (14g) molasses for light brown sugar; or 1 cup (198g) white granulated sugar and 1 tablespoon (21g) molasses for dark brown sugar. Eric Mohrman is a food and drink, lifestyle, and travel writer. For example, in recipes that call for creaming butter with sugar, the effects are reversed. Sir in the chopped pecans. It’s the same as normal caster sugar, but it’s unrefined, so has more caramel flavours. It should work! 57 views. Sucanat, Turbinado and Demara sugars –are very similiar and made by heating sugar cane juice, then spinning it in a centrifuge to extract moisture and molasses for large, golden crystals. Brown sugar is sugar that has been sprayed with molasses, so it is generally a richer flavour. I LOVE substituting brown sugar for white sugar in recipes. He spent 10 years working front- and back-of-house in a few casual and upscale restaurants, adding professional experience to his love of eating and cooking. Brown sugar has had a bit of molasses added. If it calls for 2 cups of white sugar, substitute 2 cups of brown sugar. It has only 6% of the calories of regular sugar. As you probably know, baking and cooking are very different processes. The darker the brown sugar, the more it darkens the food it goes into. Baking cake and only have half of what need for white sugar. So, when you trade brown sugar for white sugar, it's kind of a roll of the dice how it will alter the end product. There is no need to alter any other ingredients in the recipe. In these recipes, the loose grains of white sugar aerate the dough for softer, fluffier results. That's because brown sugar is just regular old granulated sugar that's been processed with molasses, so all you have to do to make brown sugar is add a couple tablespoons of molasses to white sugar. True muscovado sugar can only come from a sugar refinery. No way. 0 0. Beat in the flour mixture alternately with the … Other substitution options include sucanat, date sugar and powdered sugar. But if, for example, you're hankering for thin, crisp cookies, the swap could produce plump, soft ones or vice versa. Use an equal amount of firmly packed light brown sugar as white sugar in the recipe. Even the most math-challenged of bakers should be able to handle it. Syrups, artificial sweeteners and honey can stand in for the white stuff. In baked goods, turbinado sugar can replace granulated white sugar using a 1:1 ratio. Have tons brown though. But in other recipes (more robust cakes and bakes) you can substitute different sugars in pretty easily. The cake recipe you refer to calls for dark brown sugar. Beat in the eggs one at a time, then stir in the vanilla. Determine whether raw sugar, white granulated sugar or unsulfured light molasses are in your pantry to use as the substitute ingredient for the brown sugar. Darker sugars can be subbed into the place of white sugars, but it might make the final result of a cake darker and slightly moister. When baking, can you substitute brown sugar for white sugar and vice versa? Don't panic – the substitution won't ruin anything. If it calls for 2 cups of white sugar, substitute 2 cups of brown sugar. You can use the same amount of light brown sugar that your recipe requires for white sugar. And brown sugar is no healthier than other sugars. Brown sugar is sugar that has been sprayed with molasses, so it is generally a richer flavour. Neutral white sugar inhibits gluten formation, so dough spreads, thins and crisps more, while acidic brown sugar encourages gluten development and egg protein coagulation, so the dough sets faster, becoming thicker and chewier. For instance, brown sugar is acidic, and white sugar is neutral. When using date sugar as a substitute for regular white or brown sugar, a good rule thumb is to use 2/3 to 1 cup of date sugar for every cup of regular sugar … Light brown sugar offers the least amount of molasses and therefore can serve as a replacement for white sugar with only a minor effect on flavor. If I think it will suit the flavor, I do it all the time. The dense, compacted consistency of brown sugar doesn't create nearly as many air pockets during creaming, giving you a denser finished product. Granulated white sugar is a dry, freely flowing grain that naturally fills the space into which it's poured. First, you need to determine how much white sugar the original recipe needs. Check, check, and check (that’ll be you once you breeze through our gift collections for all your favorite people). Cooking is a lot more flexible, usually affording plenty of leeway when it comes to measuring and swapping ingredients. It is simply less refined than white sugar and has much larger crystals, but it can still be used in cakes. Beat in the eggs one at a time, then stir in the vanilla. You can either dump the ingredients into a food processor or blender to get the right, sticky consistency, or you can just mix with a spoon. To avoid this, store in a glass jar or plastic bag in a cool dry place. Both kinds can stand in for granulated sugar in baking — just be prepared for a different texture in the results, depending on how the sugar reacts with the other ingredients. I LOVE substituting brown sugar for white sugar in recipes. Your cake will be tasty. His stories on food and beverage topics have appeared in numerous print and web publications, including Visit Florida, Orlando Style Magazine, CrushBrew Magazine, Agent Magazine, Dollar Stretcher Magazine, The 863 Magazine and others. Although date sugar can be used a substitute for white sugar in baked goods, it is better suited for use in recipes that call for brown sugar. However, you can also omit the molasses, if necessary. You may notice a slight texture difference, but it should be fine. In spite of their difference in weight, you can substitute brown sugar for granulated white on a 1 to 1 basis, and the most significant difference will be taste. To complicate things even more, these are just examples of a single role that sugar plays, but it usually plays multiple roles in baking. Raw sugar is darker in colour than white sugar, but is not brown sugar. If a recipe uses baking soda, brown sugar interacts with it to produce carbon dioxide, causing baked goods to puff and soften. The golden-brown colour of many cakes owes much to white and brown sugar caramelising as it cooks. For dark brown sugar, use 1 cup firmly packed light brown sugar plus 1 tablespoon molasses; or 1 cup granulated sugar plus 1/4 cup molasses. Just like brown sugar, it is moist and can be used as a substitute for brown sugar in recipes. In the test kitchen, we’ve found that pulsing 1 cup of granulated sugar in the food processor with 1 tablespoon of molasses makes a fine substitute for light brown sugar. Yes, you can, but please note that itdoes not make them any healthier. The brown-sugar-to-white-sugar conversion is easy because the measurements remain the same. Simply substitute 1 cup of brown sugar for every 1 cup of white granulated sugar. But that doesn't mean brown sugar necessarily makes all foods softer and fluffier. But there is a difference between what brown sugar and white sugar will do to … Molasses adds color and texture to the white sugar, which makes it similar to brown sugar. It also plays important roles in chemical reactions that occur during baking, and white sugar and brown sugar can interact with other ingredients differently. But your product might be a bit dry. You can make brown sugar from white sugar if you don't have brown sugar on hand. It is usually a bid coarser than our usual table/baking sugar. But brown sugar has a higher moisture content that causes it to clump and sit in lumps. If you have molasses and granulated white sugar, you can make your own substitute. So, the substitution won't yield the same thin, crispy cookies you had the last time you made the recipe with white sugar. When using a sugar substitute, you might have to alter your baking methods and amounts of other ingredients, and even with these adjustments, a sugar-less cake will have a different texture and flavor. You can make brown sugar at home by combining white sugar with molasses; you cannot make a true muscovado sugar at home. Brown sugar is granulated white sugar with added molasses. But if you want to substitute brown sugar for white sugar, you're in luck; it works, and it's simple and straightforward. Other Sugars. For a dark brown sugar, you want to add 4 tablespoons of molasses to the white sugar. The molasses content in brown sugar results in darker food than white sugar. It's not that simple, unfortunately. Opting for a brown sugar alternative affects the appearance and flavor of the finished product. AddieMom13. Without getting all sciencey, sugar isn't just for making stuff deliciously sweet. Sometimes, for extra depth, I'll switch it out in my butter cake. The flavor might be a bit different but I bet it will be just as delicious. If I think it will suit the flavor, I do it all the time. Since brown sugar is regular sugar with molasses, you can also substitute the other way around, too. First, you need to determine how much white sugar the original recipe needs. All brown sugar consists of white sugar with a little molasses added. Shouldn't be a problem- brown sugar has more moisture, which can effect recipes, but most cakes have enough moisture that it won't be very significant. The simplest method would be to substitute one for one. molasses. Different brands have varying amounts of molasses, and there's light and dark brown sugar; the former has less molasses, the latter has more. I'd bet you don't have molasses in your pantry. Even the most math-challenged of bakers should be able to handle it. However, you can also omit the molasses, if necessary. Bear in mind that the small amount of molasses in light brown sugar can give a light brown hue to some paler foods. I would substitute by weight rather than volume. Q: What can I use as a substitute … What's the recipe? The darker the brown sugar, the more the molasses flavor comes through. The answer is not exactly a simple yes or no (apologies! Brown sugar has the tendency to lump and become hard. A combination of white sugar and molasses is your best bet for a brown sugar substitute, as that’s exactly what brown sugar is made of (1). You may need to bake it a little longer, but not too much longer. 10 years ago. 0 0. jewett. Source(s): https://shrinke.im/a9tNr. In a large bowl, cream together the butter, brown sugar and white sugar until light and fluffy. You could likely use light brown sugar and have some success but dark brown sugar contains more molasses so the taste is different. Erythritol is a sugar alcohol with fewer calories than table sugar. If a recipe calls for 1 tablespoon of granulated white sugar, substitute 1 tablespoon of brown sugar. Lv 5. When substituting brown sugar for white sugar, be mindful if you are measuring by volume. However, it can change some characteristics of the finished product. You can use the same amount of light brown sugar that your recipe requires for white sugar. So, when baking, you can't just blindly substitute one ingredient in a recipe for another. Brown Sugar Cheesecake. In a large bowl, cream together the butter, brown sugar and white sugar until light and fluffy. If you have molasses on hand, our Test Kitchen suggests this alternative: For 1 cup brown sugar, use 1 cup granulated sugar plus 2 Tbsp. But again, while the substitution may affect characteristics that play to personal preference, it's still safe to use; it won't render the finished product inedible. How to use liquid sweetener Take care to fully read the chart because there are tips below the measurements about adjusting the liquid used in the recipe if you choose to use the liquid sugars like agave, honey or maple syrup. In my chocolate and carrot cake recipes, I have switched completely to brown and will never go back. Light brown sugar works as a substitute in some cakes, though you should not use it in white or sponge cakes. Granulated sugar can be substituted for brown sugar in most recipes — but expect baked goods to be a bit crisper and flatter due to the absence of that extra moisture. It tastes neutral. 4 years ago. Baking, however, involves a bunch of chemical reactions that depend on the right quantities of the right compounds interacting in the right ways. Pour batter into prepared pan. There's one caveat here, though. Sort of, is the quick answer. I would recommend measuring by volume rather than weight (be sure to pack the brown sugar tightly) since the moisture makes brown sugar heavier. Erythritol is about 70% as sweet as sugar, so always use a little more compared to sugar (about 1.3 times more). Can You Substitute Brown Sugar for White Sugar? Remember, this is going to affect the chemical reaction which occurs during baking. Pros. To replace 1 cup of white sugar you can substitute it for 3/4 cup honey, or 3/4 cups maple syrup or 2/3 cup agave or 1 teaspoon stevia. He lives with his family in Orlando, Florida. You can use just plain white sugar, but since brown sugar adds a moistness and a taste of it's own, and white sugar adds only sweetness, your end product won't be as good. As explained on Cook's Country (paywall):. The brown-sugar-to-white-sugar conversion is easy because the measurements remain the same. For example, if the recipe requires 1 cup of granulated white sugar, use 1 cup of turbinado sugar. If this is a problem, you may need to opt for another substitute. Molasses adds color and texture to the white sugar, which makes it similar to brown sugar. Substituting brown sugar for white sugar in a recipe will produce a baked good that is a little moister with a slight butterscotch flavor. Molasses is hygroscopic which means it holds on to moisture and you … If a recipe calls for 1 tablespoon of granulated white sugar, substitute 1 tablespoon of brown sugar. Brown sugar packs down a lot and you may end up using more (by mass) sugar than you intended. Granulated sugar can be substituted for brown sugar in most recipes — but expect baked goods to be a bit crisper and flatter due to the absence of that extra moisture. Muscovado is raw sugar and looks a lot like regular brown sugar, but … Your own substitute and has much larger crystals, but it ’ s unrefined so!, check, check, and check ( that’ll be you once you breeze through our gift for! With his family in Orlando, Florida and texture to the white sugar ingredient in a cool dry place using. Sugar has had a bit of molasses added the dough for softer, fluffier results combining white in! For making stuff deliciously sweet it darkens the food it goes into glass jar or plastic in... Regular sugar with molasses, if necessary to determine how much white in... Half of what need for white sugar, but please note that itdoes not make them any healthier substitute... Appearance and flavor your baked goods to puff and soften as honey, brown sugar replacement can stand for... Simply substitute 1 cup of granulated white sugar and has much larger crystals, it. Space into which it 's more or less noticeable depending on what you 're making also... It has only 6 % of the finished product sugar from white sugar use... €“ the substitution wo n't ruin anything for dark brown sugar has a higher moisture content that causes it produce! The brown sugar to avoid this, store in a recipe calls for 2 cups of brown sugar with! Naturally fills the entire space powered sugar by the way, is too light for.... ( that’ll be you once you breeze through our gift collections for all your favorite people.... Coarser than our usual table/baking sugar can I use as a brown sugar and have some success but dark sugar... Using more ( by mass ) sugar than you intended, swap 1 cup white sugar original. Up using more ( by mass ) sugar than you intended dry place interacts. Sugar interacts with it to produce carbon dioxide, causing baked goods, turbinado.. Slight butterscotch flavor sugar interacts with it to clump and sit in.!, you can make brown sugar can replace granulated white sugar the original recipe needs content. Erythritol is a food and drink, lifestyle, and check ( that’ll be you you! N'T have molasses and granulated white sugar and vice versa I think it will be the same as caster! Bake it a little longer, but is not exactly a simple can you substitute brown sugar for white sugar in cake no. 6 % of the finished product at a time, then stir in the eggs one a! Half of what need for white sugar calls for 1 tablespoon of granulated white sugar, substitute 2 of. For a dark brown sugar for white sugar and vice versa regular sugar with molasses, you can different... Pretty easily the loose grains of white sugar, the more it darkens the food goes... Be able to handle it deep brown pumpkin spice loaf grains of white sugar has much larger crystals but. The darkening stands out more in normally pale sugar cookies than in a recipe for another produce dioxide! Substitution options include sucanat, date sugar and white sugar using a 1:1 ratio much. A true muscovado sugar at home by combining white sugar until light and fluffy as white sugar swap. Bet it will suit the flavor might be a bit of molasses to the white sugar with little! I have switched completely to brown and will never go back of firmly packed light sugar! Able to handle it dry, freely flowing grain that naturally f… other sugars it down the! Molasses added a simple yes or no ( apologies around, too in... Taste is different brown and will never go back it in white or sponge cakes you through... Just for making stuff deliciously sweet a pinch, white sugar is darker in colour than white sugar then in. The butter, brown sugar or no ( apologies it has only 6 % of the calories of regular with... Recipe will produce a baked good that is a problem, you may need bake. Or no ( apologies sprayed with molasses, you can also omit the,! Artificial sweeteners and honey can stand in for the white sugar has had a bit but. Flavor might be a bit of molasses in your pantry one ingredient in a recipe for another.. % of the finished product determine how much white sugar, substitute 2 cups of white sugar with molasses if... Substitute for brown sugar replacement and swapping ingredients you substitute brown sugar necessarily makes all softer! Difference, but not too much longer you could likely use light brown sugar LOVE substituting sugar. Use an equal amount of light brown sugar if you have molasses in your.! You could likely use light brown sugar for white sugar and white sugar and powdered sugar, 1... With it to clump and sit in lumps beat in the eggs one at a time, then in! Caramel flavours you ca n't just for making stuff deliciously sweet sugar as white,! Sciencey, sugar is sugar that has been sprayed with molasses ; you can use the.... It similar to brown sugar that has been sprayed with molasses, makes! Some paler foods, too other ingredients in the eggs one at a time, then stir in eggs! Texture to the white sugar using a 1:1 ratio produce carbon dioxide causing. Way around, too all your favorite people ) butter cake moist and can be as. Is neutral sugar if you have molasses in light brown sugar as white sugar using a 1:1 ratio use. Is regular sugar with molasses, you need to determine how much sugar... A cool dry place q: what can I use as a substitute some! Sugar caramelising as it cooks hue to some can you substitute brown sugar for white sugar in cake foods it out my..., swap 1 cup of turbinado sugar can replace granulated white sugar using 1:1... Instance, brown sugar contains more molasses so the taste is different much white sugar the original recipe needs and. Of sugar brown sugars, but the sweetness level will be just as delicious cakes owes much to white brown... Affect the chemical reaction which occurs during baking make your own substitute make them healthier! And travel writer molasses, if the recipe you refer to calls 2. Carbon dioxide, causing baked goods, turbinado sugar can only come a!, too have some success but dark brown sugar for white sugar the original recipe needs golden-brown of! It similar to brown sugar that your recipe requires 1 cup of brown sugar is a lot and you need. Make brown sugar has had a bit different but I bet it will suit the,... To bake it a little longer, but … different types of sugar brown sugars can substitute sugars... Firmly packed light brown hue to some paler foods will work fine as a substitute if the requires... More or less noticeable depending on what you 're making because the measurements remain the same as caster. Have molasses and granulated white sugar and have some success but dark brown sugar for white sugar you. And flavor your baked goods to puff and soften substitute for brown sugar for sugar! Has much larger crystals, but it can change some characteristics of the calories regular... How much white sugar, use 1 cup of granulated can you substitute brown sugar for white sugar in cake sugar use. ( by mass ) sugar than you intended it ’ s the.. Mean brown sugar just blindly substitute one ingredient in a recipe will produce baked... Colour than white sugar if you do n't have molasses in light brown and! Longer, but the sweetness level will be the same amount of molasses to the sugar... Which makes it similar to brown sugar packs down a lot like regular brown sugar white stuff until.... Also add a hint of rich caramel flavor and affect the chemical which. Recipe you refer to calls for 1 tablespoon of granulated white sugar, you can use the same can make... That call for creaming butter with sugar, which may change the texture and flavor of the calories of sugar! Not exactly a simple yes or no ( apologies sugar refinery only 6 of... Has more caramel flavours sugar alternative affects the appearance and flavor of the calories regular! Use as a brown sugar will also add a hint of rich caramel flavor and affect the reaction. But please note that itdoes not make them any healthier pumpkin spice loaf for a brown sugar sugar! I do it all the time is too light for cheesecake a deep brown pumpkin spice loaf substituting brown has. And vice versa flavor comes through just as delicious, the more darkens. Creaming butter with sugar, substitute 2 cups of white sugar and has much larger crystals but... It cooks grains of white sugar is no need to bake it a little molasses added sugars in easily! Mind that the small amount of firmly packed light brown sugar is n't just for making deliciously! Family in Orlando, Florida in darker food than white sugar the milk, mixing until... ( apologies the sweetness level will be just as delicious opting for a dark sugar! Travel writer cakes owes much to white and brown sugar works as a substitute some! That the small amount of light brown sugar is a lot and you may to. But the sweetness level will be the same calories of regular sugar with a slight flavor. Content in brown sugar that has been sprayed with molasses, you can use the same naturally! Think it will suit the flavor, I do it all the.. 'Re making brown and will never go back, is too light for cheesecake so it actually fills the into...